I found this article slightly interesting because when I write, I am one who uses many commas, semicolons, colons, dashes, and parenthesis. When I originally began using the higher level punctuation in my writing, I didn’t know that they were, according to grammarians, used to signal specific degrees of finality; I simply used them because they helped me put all of my ideas in one sentence.
Speaking of what I just mentioned, I believe that this led to one of my biggest issues with my writing style: I find it very difficult not to write long, wordy sentences; beginning or ending with a dependent clause and/or stringing my many ideas with mainly commas, semicolons, and dashes. Virtually whenever I have my essays peer reviewed, their number one complaint or idea on how to write my paper are that I don’t have any variance in the length of my sentences–they are all long and wordy. But, when I am physically writing the sentences, none of my ideas really feel complete unless I write things in long, wordy manner.
I found that the small cartoon above perfectly described what Dawkin’s was trying to fight against; the belief that if you don’t write grammatically correct, that your paper is horrible. In case you cannot read it:
Box 1: The wizard says, “Great job, kids! You have skills that even I’m impressed with.” The two kids can be seen tugging on words like “verb and noun”
Box 2: One of the kids in the group says, “Sir, did you just end your sentence with a preposition?”
Box 3: the wizard replies, “Kids, everyone makes mis-”
Box 4: the group of kids mauls the grammar wizard for breaking one of the many grammar rules.
In this journal article, Dawkin’s tries to get across the idea that–like Mike Rose says in “Rigid Rules, Inflexible Plans, and the Stifling of Language: A Cognitivist Analysis of Writer’s Block”–grammar rules should only be used as a guideline for writing, but, in order to reach an upper level of writing, one must break these rules.









