John Dawkin’s “Teaching Punctuation as a Rhetorical Tool”

I found this article slightly interesting because when I write, I am one who uses many commas, semicolons, colons, dashes, and parenthesis.  When I originally began using the higher level punctuation in my writing, I didn’t know that they were, according to grammarians, used to signal specific degrees of finality; I simply used them because they helped me put all of my ideas in one sentence.

Speaking of what I just mentioned, I believe that this led to one of my biggest issues with my writing style: I find it very difficult not to write long, wordy sentences; beginning or ending with a dependent clause and/or stringing my many ideas with mainly commas, semicolons, and dashes.  Virtually whenever I have my essays peer reviewed, their number one complaint or idea on how to write my paper are that I don’t have any variance in the length of my sentences–they are all long and wordy.  But, when I am physically writing the sentences, none of my ideas really feel complete unless I write things in long, wordy manner.

PBF099-Grammar_Wizard

 

I found that the small cartoon above perfectly described what Dawkin’s was trying to fight against; the belief that if you don’t write grammatically correct, that your paper is horrible.  In case you cannot read it:

Box 1: The wizard says, “Great job, kids!  You have skills that even I’m impressed with.”  The two kids can be seen tugging on words like “verb and noun”

Box 2: One of the kids in the group says, “Sir, did you just end your sentence with a preposition?”

Box 3: the wizard replies, “Kids, everyone makes mis-”

Box 4: the group of kids mauls the grammar wizard for breaking one of the many grammar rules.

In this journal article, Dawkin’s tries to get across the idea that–like Mike Rose says in “Rigid Rules, Inflexible Plans, and the Stifling of Language: A Cognitivist Analysis of Writer’s Block”–grammar rules should only be used as a guideline for writing, but, in order to reach an upper level of writing, one must break these rules.

Joseph M. Williams’ “The Phenomenology of Error”

I found the topic of discussion to be fairly interesting but the article itself to be quite the opposite until I reached the last portion to be honest; I didn’t really understand the article until I reached the which vs that section and from there on, I continually went in and out of understanding what the article was talking about.

However, throughout the article I was continually wondering if while analyzing how other authors disobey their own writing rules, if he was doing the same.  That was the one thing that I did for sure completely understand because he continually stated that he wasn’t interested in parallelism or the particular typo, but, rather that he is interested in how people recognize (even the author) and respond to the errors they make while writing and/or reading.  My answer to the question about whether or not he made typos while writing this particular article was answered in the final portion where he explains that the entire article in itself was to be used for research into this area and that there were in fact, “about 100 errors.”

This led me to become fairly interested in the organization and structure of the article.  I say this because up to this point, we have not read any articles where the article itself was meant to research and test the area being discussed; this is not revealed until the end of the article.  I especially found it interesting because in the final section, he says:

“Don’t go back and reread, looking for errors, at least not before you recall what errors you found the first time through…If you want to go through a second time and look for errors, better yet.  Just make clear if you would, that your list is the result of a deliberate search.” (WAW 51)

I now wonder if the reason I didn’t really understand a majority of the article was the result of these errors.

Image

Dennis Baron’s “From Pencils to Pixels: The Stages of Literacy Technologies”

In this article, Dennis Baron reviews the history of different forms of communication and how they eventually ended up transforming our world into a more technological society.  He starts by explaining the process in which writing came about and the ideals that originally confronted it; he then concludes the article with the computer and ponders the many ideas about what may come as a result of the computer.  This article was written in 1999, so, I found it kind of interesting to see what someone back then thought the computer and the world wide web may develop into and how it will affect society as a whole.

Overall, I found this article to be very interesting!! I have always been a person who really enjoyed history and I learned a lot of things about the pencil that–like Baron says–I often overlooked because of its simplicity.  I never realized how much controversy could be made over something as simple as a pencil and how much it truly affected society (especially when the eraser was introduced to the pencil!!!)

I found the introduction also to be very interesting because of what “futurologists”  believed the computer would be in today’s society:

“The Governor of Illinois thinks that hooking up every school classroom to the Web will eliminate illeteracy.  In his secont-term victory speech, President Clinton promised to have every eight-year-old reading, and to connect every twelve-year-old to the National Information Infrastructure.  Futurologists write books predicting that computers will replace books.  Newspapers rush to hook online subscribers.  The New York Times will download the Sunday Crossword puzzle, time me as I fill in the answers from my keyboard, even score my results.  They’ll worry later about how to get me to pay for this service.” (WAW 423)

I think this excerpt is pretty interesting when comparing it to where technology is today in 2013.  I’m not necessarily sure about how it has increased or decreased literacy of the people but it is pretty evident that most people in the middle class and higher have a computer not only with word processors but also the internet (or in more archaic terms…the World Wide Web).  Also, many magazines and books now-a-days can be read online or on mini-computers known as E-readers.

Image

James Paul Gee’s “Literacy, Discourse and Linguistics: Introduction”

In this article, James Paul Gee explores the idea of the acquisition of primary and secondary Discourses.  He states that primary Discourse is “the one we first use to make sense of the world and interact with others…our original and home-based sense of identity,” (WAW 485).  He then continues on to state that our secondary Discourse are the ones we learn  “After our initial socialization in our home community, each of us interacts with various non-home-based social institutions…Each of these social institutions commands and demands one or more Discourses and we acquire these fluently to the extent that we are given access to these institutions and are allowed apprenticeships within them,” (WAW 485).

To be quite honest, I didn’t really understand much of this article at all; especially when he started going into the part about the storybook.  I say this because in the “CONTEXT OF THE TEXT” section, Gee states that the mother was reading to the 7-year-old and that the 5-year-old said that she wanted to read; but, I couldn’t really tell if the following story was that of what happened at the 5-year-old’s birthday party or what happened in the book that the mother was reading to the 7-year -old daughter because the author says that she didn’t read at all.  I read this section several times and still haven’t been able to decode the underlying meaning to this section and how it has anything to what he had previously discussed about the acquisition of secondary Discourses.

Another thing I didn’t necessarily understand was the part that I just mentioned above about the acquisition of secondary Discourses.  In this part he says, “A Discourse is an integration of saying, doing, and valuing, and all socially based valuing is political.  All successful teaching, that is, teaching that inculcates Discourse and not just content, is political,” (WAW 490).  Although the “Framing the Reading Section” says not to take what Gee says literally but I honestly don’t have any idea on how Gee came to the conclusion that everything we learn is political.

Image

Margaret Kantz’ “Helping Students Use Textual Sources Persuasively”

in this article, Margaret Kant–an old student of Linda Flower and classmate with Christina Haas–explores the concept of reading and writing rhetorically–specifically on the topic of synthesis essays.  One thing I found interesting about this article is when she discusses how students believe they should be able to write something in a single draft perfectly; and if they can’t write something in a single draft, they get the feeling that they are a failure as a writer.

From past experience, I am more than certain that I am one of these students.  Although I may not consider myself a failure when this occurs, I begin to feel as if there is either something wrong with either the assignment or me.  Also, I have noticed that once I finish my first draft–with the exception of minor grammar changes–that it is very difficult for me to erase anything that I have written.  I’m not necessarily sure of the cause of this but I believe that it may be a form of writers block.  I say this because it often takes me a fair amount of time to write something to what I believe not necessarily to be perfection, but, a piece that I feel I’ve expanded my thoughts to the best of my ability.

I felt that the picture below was well suited for this blog post because it kind of explains my writing process.  Even though I often mention many things within my essays–especially research essays–I often find that I don’t add to the conversation.  This was one of several topics discussed by Kantz.  She claims that most students don’t know how to properly write synthesis essays and that often times this leads to what would be considered plagiarism.  This occurs because the students do a fine job at finding and writing about their topics, but, they don’t know how to had individual thought or commentary to the conversation in the discourse group.

EPSON scanner image

 

Christina Haas and Linda Flower’s “Rhetorical Reading Strategies and the Construction of Meaning”

In the article, “Rhetorical Reading Strategies and the Construction of Meaning”, Haas and Flower conducted a study in order to better understand the following two questions of the reading and writing process of college freshman in comparison to more advanced readers:

1) “How does this constructive [rhetorical reading] process play itself out in the actual, thinking process of reading?” (WAW 122)

2) “Are all readers really aware of or in control of the discourse act which current theories describe?” (WAW 122)

By the end of the article, Haas and Flower come to the conclusion that even though both student writers and advanced readers are able to understand the overall “meaning” of a text, it was realized rather more quickly by advanced readers.  They also concluded that student writers focus more on writing about how content leads to the overall meaning; on the other hand, advanced writers focused more on the rhetorical situation the author must have been in in order to lead to the overall meaning of the text.

I found this article fairly interesting because I found myself comparing my own writing experiences with what the authors were claiming as I read through this article.  In AP English, we were often assigned anagrams that were to help us have a basic understanding of all the things we could analyze in our essays so that we could convey the greater meaning of the text.  I don’t exactly remember what any of these anagrams were but a majority of them involved identifying the speaker, the tone, rhetorical devices, connotation, etc.  These anagrams however never really helped me that I am consciously aware of but I am unsure as to why I say this.

Another thing I realized while reading this is that it would have been a perfect article for my process analysis topic if I were to slightly change my topic.  One problem I had while writing my process analysis was that there was not research specifically dealing with my topic.  But, as I continued on through my paper, I realized that I don’t necessarily incompletely develop my thoughts while writing timed essays but also in general writing.  This is one of several topics that Haas and Flower discuss in this article.  They came to the conclusion that most student writers focus more solely on writing a summary of the content; on the other hand, however, advanced readers and writers were able to go more into how the rhetorical situation surrounding the author could have possibly led to the greater meaning.  I really wish I had found this article while writing that essay!

?????????????????????????????????

Anne Lamott’s “Shitty First Drafts”

In “Shitty First Drafts,” Lamott explains the way in which she experiences anxiety while writing essays and how she overcomes it.  In a less scientific way, this article gives the writer’s perspective on the topic of writer’s block–a topic that was discussed by Mike Rose in “Rigid Rules, Inflexible Plans, and the Stifling of Language: a Cognitivists Analysis of Writers Block.”  As I expressed in a previous blog post, Rose discusses that the reasons that seem to cause writer’s block are due to the fact that they turned the general guidelines that they were taught as young children into law.  However, Lamott explains that not only her, but many other authors go into panic mode before writing a new piece and often don’t know their directions until they finish their first draft.

“I know some very great writers, writers you love who write beautifully and have made a great deal of money, and not one of them writes elegant first drafts.  All right [Alright], one of them does, but we do not like her very much,” (WAW, 301).  Out of the entire article, I found this excerpt to be especially funny—I’m not entirely sure why, but, for some reason this thought stuck out to me as a reader.

Overall, however, I can’t really say I liked this piece.  Whether it was the style or the tone in which she uses, it just didn’t click with me; this kind of surprised me though because simply based on the title, I could tell that this piece was going to have a humorous undertone—and I myself, find many things to be fairly humorous.  So, I’m not exactly sure why I wasn’t too fond of this piece

shitty-first-drafts-spread

While I was googling an image under the topic of “shitty first drafts,” this one simply stood out to me out of the rest of the images because of the artwork.  I found that it perfectly showed what Lamott was said; that most authors don’t know their direction until they finish their first draft.  I felt this picture perfectly illustrated that idea because there is a bear with a chicken’s head and a tortoise/turtle (I don’t know the difference!!) with the head of a dog.  So, in other words, the images portrayed in this photo don’t really make sense, other than the fact that it shows that, like first drafts, the ideas portrayed don’t necessarily make any sense at all.

 

Mike Rose’s “Rigid Rules, Inflexible Plans, and the Stifling of Language: A Cognitivist Analysis of Writer’s Block”

In this article, Mike Rose delves into a study in which he examines the the writing processes of ten people and analyzes these processes to see what some of the underlying causes writer’s block might be.  Of these ten people, Rose has five “blockers” and five “non-blockers”.  Being a person of science—specifically medicine and biology—I found this article to be the most interesting of all the articles that we have read up to this point because one of the conclusions that Rose comes to is that the process of the human mind is one of the main causes for writer’s block…surprise, surprise!!  

Before I began reading this article, I thought the findings of Rose would be a lot more complicated and would end up explaining something about the chemicals within our brains that cause writer’s block; but, instead he came to the conclusion that “the these rules seem to be followed as though they were algorithms, absolute dicta, rather than the lose heuristics that they were intended to be” (WAW, 245-246).  In the latter excerpt, Rose explains that the general writing rules we are taught as children—making an outline; writing a five paragraph paper in which we have an introductory paragraph, three body paragraphs, and a concluding paragraph; and writing to a targeted audience—as well as how the human mind processes these rules are the leading cause to writer’s block.  Some cases obviously being more serious than others.  So, what I am curious about and would like to possibly research myself when I get older, is what exactly is going on in the brain that determines whether one will become a “blocker” or a “non-blocker”?  What causes one person to strictly follow the rules and another to not really cognitively follow these rules.

I felt that the below picture was appropriate for this article because it obviously is titled “Rules” and is followed with an unfinished lists of cans and cannots, the same things that cause “blockers” to suffer from writer’s block.

Image

Carol Berkenkotter’s “Decisions and Revisions: The Planning Strategies of a Publishing Writer” and Donald M. Murray’s “Response of a Laboratory Rat–or, Being Protocoled”

In ” Decisions and Revisions: The Planning Strategies of a Publishing Writer,” Carol Berkenkotter describes a “lab” that she performed on Donald M. Murray to better understand how professional writer’s revise their work; in “Response of a Laboratory Rat–or, Being Protocoled,” Murray discusses not only how he felt about being a “lab rat”, but also what he took away from the experience.

Starting in the result section (Berkenkotter), the author began inserting excerpts primarily from the audio tapes Murray recorded while he was working.  I personally found these excerpts to be a “space waster”–in other words, a space that the author could have written more about her results or simply not written anything at all.  Even though the excerpts are Murray randomly talking to himself about his work, which is exactly what it came off as to me–a bunch of gibberish.  Often during these times, I found my thoughts wondering and no matter how many times I re-read a section, my mind found that it was nothing but gibberish in the end.  To me, the excerpts didn’t necessarily clarify the preceding paragraph and that I didn’t really find the following paragraph to explain how that excerpt has anything to do with her findings.  But, maybe I didn’t read this piece close enough.

As for the piece by Murray, I found it to be more readable than Berkenkotter’s article.  He said that after the experience, he felt that he had actually learned more about his writing by being a “lab rat”.  In section 5, Murray says that he was surprised by how much time he actually spent planning his writing.  For me, I feel that I don’t do much planning at all; I feel that when I write, I chose a general topic and a general structure and just begin typing whatever I feel is appropriate with the direction that my writing ends up taking.

Berkenkotter and Murray

 

I felt that this picture was appropriate in describing not only how Murray thinks while planning his writings, but also how Murray’s excerpts seem to just be randomly placed in her article, “Decisions and Revisions: The Planning Strategies of a Publishing Writer”, to take up more space.

James E Porter’s “Intertextuality and the Discourse Community”

In this article, James E. Porter investigates the subject of intertextuality–the belief that all texts contain “traces” of other texts and that there is no text that doesn’t take at least one idea or thought from another person.  He further develops the idea through the terms “iterability”–the “repeatability” of a text–and “presupposition”–the assumptions that arise from such texts.

As I read this article, I found it miraculous how similar this article was with an article we read a few days ago by Keith Grant-Davie.  Although they may not have used the exact same terms, they both explored the ideas of exigence, rhetors, audience and constraints in discourse.  

Grant-Davie definied exigence as a problem or a need that can be addressed through communication and discourse; one way in which Porter backed up this definition was by stating that the readers create rhetorical situations through “discourse communities,” or an audience.  Porter defines the audience as a group of individuals with common interests that communicate “through approved channels”–a.k.a. forums–and that their discourse in controlled by an established form of ethos.  An example he gave of one of these groups was the medical community.  Previous to talking about the discourse community, Porter says,

       “By identifying and stressing the intertextual nature of discourse…we shift our attention away from the writer as individual and focus more on the sources and social contexts from which the writer’s discourse arises.  According to this view, authorial intention is less significant that social context; the writer is simply a part of a discourse tradition, a member of a team, and a participant in a community of discourse that creates its own collective meaning.  Thus the intertext constrains writing.” (WAW, 88)

Just in that single passage, Porter addresses all five topics that Keith Grant-Davie discusses in his article Rhetorical Situations and Their Constitituents.  I found the similarities between these two articles to be strikingly similar and that in the end, both authors simply want to promote young writers to write effectively in the areas of their study.  

Image

 

The above picture illustrates another “discourse community;” This group shows a group of first responders that are in different branches, but overall, work for the justice department.